
Reviewed for patch 7.3f

Favorable matchup
Reviewed for patch 7.3f
What defines Poppy in lane is Steadfast Presence, and against Cho'Gath it has nothing to stop: none of his abilities moves him. On top of that, Feast deals true damage, which doesn't go through the resistances she gains when she's low.
Steadfast Presence gives Poppy movement speed and stops enemy dashes around her. Cho'Gath fights standing still: Rupture lands on an area, Feral Scream comes out in a cone and Vorpal Spikes rides on his attacks. All Poppy gets out of it is the speed.
Steadfast Presence's passive gives her armor and magic resist, and more when she's low on health, which is when other laners fail to finish her. Feast deals a high amount of true damage: that extra resistance doesn't count for the final blow.
Feral Scream silences for a few seconds. While silenced, Poppy can't use Heroic Charge to carry you into a wall or Keeper's Verdict to send you out of the fight. That's the moment to place Rupture and hit her with Vorpal Spikes.
Last-hit calmly and heal up with Carnivore until you have Feast. From then on, every trade that leaves Poppy low is a kill threat, no matter how much her passive toughens her up.
If you play Poppy, don't count on Steadfast Presence to win the trade: use it for the speed, to leave the Rupture area or the Feral Scream cone. Look for short trades next to a wall, pick up the Iron Ambassador shield and back off before you're low within Feast range.

Favorable matchup
Reviewed for patch 7.3f
Poppy wants short trades: hammer, charge into the wall and out. Darius wins when the trade drags on, because Hemorrhage keeps dealing damage after they split and Apprehend brings her back. And his basic abilities have no dash for her to stop.
Hemorrhage makes Darius's attacks and damaging abilities leave a stacking bleed. Poppy can leave the trade with the speed from Steadfast Presence, but the bleed leaves with her. At full stacks, Darius gains Noxian Might and more attack damage.
Apprehend passively makes Darius's physical damage ignore a percentage of the target's armor, and part of what Poppy gains from her passive is armor. The active pulls her to you: it's how you extend a trade she thought was over.
Decimate deals more damage with the blade than with the handle and heals Darius for each enemy champion hit by the blade. Poppy fights right on top of you, in handle range: take a step back before the swing lands.
Once Hemorrhage has several stacks, the trade is yours. Until then, hit her when she walks up to last-hit and don't chase: the short trade is still hers.
As Poppy, trades have to last as long as your combo does. Go in with Hammer Shock and Heroic Charge into a wall, and leave with Steadfast Presence before Hemorrhage stacks up. Keep Keeper's Verdict to send Darius away when he has Noxian Might, not to start the fight.

Execution matters
Reviewed for patch 7.3f
Olaf is here on one condition: Ragnarok. While it lasts he is immune to disables, and the Heroic Charge stun into a wall stops being a threat. Without the ultimate, Poppy has two clear answers: the wall, and Steadfast Presence against Reckless Swing.
Ragnarok makes Olaf immune to disables for a while. Poppy's trade depends on stunning with Heroic Charge into a wall; with Ragnarok active you can fight next to your tower or at the river entrance without that stun deciding anything.
Reckless Swing deals true damage, which doesn't go through the armor or magic resist from Poppy's passive. The price: it's a dash to the enemy, exactly what Steadfast Presence stops. Cast it once she has already spent it.
Poppy brings her opponents low to finish them with the wall combo. Against Olaf, that last stretch is where he deals the most damage: Berserker Rage gives him attack speed and physical vamp based on his missing health and Vicious Strikes adds more attack speed.
Look for the all-in with Ragnarok available and Poppy's Steadfast Presence just spent. Before the ultimate, play the wave away from walls and poke with Undertow.
Playing Poppy, keep track of Olaf's ultimate. Without Ragnarok, hold Steadfast Presence for Reckless Swing and look for the wall with Heroic Charge. With Ragnarok active, don't spend the combo trying to stun him: walk away with the speed from Steadfast Presence and come back when it ends.